Manga Rating: 5.0/10.0

So, I saw this on OneManga a few days ago and thought: What the hell? This better be time worthy. And what do you know? It isn’t. But don’t get me wrong – I’m really opinionated so I might think that while others love this. Now, I’ll tell you why I don’t like this Manga (hereafter “Doujin”) and will contradict myself right now by saying that I’ll still read it to the end.

First of all, when I first see the Nagato Yuki in this story I had little trouble differentiating her. She has a… “unique look.” But as I read on this story, I can’t help but whine at how poorly drawn she was and how she looks so much like a man in a yaoi Doujin. Yes, I said it: I think the author of this Doujin, Puyo, is really an author of various yaoi Manga which is obviously directed at women. Fact is, women like things involving homosexuals – men and women.

The next thing which really made me queasy was that Nagato Yuki was not Nagato Yuki. She had little to no attributes to Yuki except for the fact that she “kind of” looks like her. So, if you ask me this Doujin is one of those shit using a name in their brand just to gather more viewers – and you know what? It works. I’m being completely honest here. The mere fact it involves Yuki is why I’m reading it. If this Doujin were to have used any other character name that I do not know of I promise you that I will refuse to read it with such vehement reluctance similar to that of a man trying to escape the rape of a homosexual rapist.

This was kind of cute and funny, but not really.

Kyon does not look like Kyon much, really. And Ryoko, she only has slight similarities. What could have been made better is if the artist (who is the author) found a real artist who could draw the characters well. That way, these corny plots will at least have some value to it. What is that value? The fact that they look like the real characters in Haruhi Suzumiya.

You can easily tell here that the main characters are not Mikuru and Tsuruya. They look like the ugliest bitches you can find as a homeless. What can you say about this? The author obviously doesn’t like Tsuruya or Mikuru as she (or he, but I don’t think any man would ever use the name “Puyo” lest he is bicurious) showed little effort in making the two look half as nice as Nagato Yuki.

So the rating I gave was 5 and by now you should probably have a sense of why.

DIGRESSION:

This reminds me… I should be watching the “second season” of Haruhi Suzumiya…

Related posts:

• Is Negi’s future waifu going to be Ku Fei?
• Being an Otaku Sucks #3 – Real Girls
• Kampfer – Where’s the morning woody?
• In Kampfer, is Natsuru homosexual or straight?
• Ladies VS Butlers – 01 – The new Negisihi: Hino